Shananagins

June Graphic Novel Reviews (and a note about Infinite Jest)

June 30, 2009 · 9 Comments

In June, I read a bunch, well seven, graphic novels including the first volume of three different series.  I usually don’t read this many this close together, but I think it might have had to do with starting to read David Foster Wallace’s Infinite Jest this month with Infinite Summer.  Although it’s a pretty involving book, lots of characters, a non-linear narrative, and a thesaurus sized vocabulary, it’s supposed to be very rewarding if you trust Wallace’s story telling ability.  Also, when (if?) I finish it, I’m going to feel all kinds of accomplished.  I really love it so far, even though the story seems disparate, there’s cross references (without specifics being mentioned) throughout, and I’m enjoying where the ride is taking me.

Anyway, I checked out all these graphic novels from the library because I wanted something not too complex, but still very fun, to read while starting Infinite Jest.  I wasn’t sure if I could handle starting it and another novel at the same time.  I doubt this will continue, because according to the schedule, I should be done with Infinite Jest by September.

I’ve never attempted to write a book review before, so bear with me.  I’m starting small with these mini-reviews and just sharing a short summary and whatever thoughts I have.

Understanding Comics by Scott McCloud

In Understanding Comics: The Invisible Art, Scott McCloud attempts to do exactly what the title states, help you to understand comics.  McCloud is not only incredibly knowledgable on the subject, but also able to relate the information in a very fun, entertaining, and easy to grasp way.  He starts with defining comics, not as easy a task as you would think, and then goes into the history of comics, starting at cave painting (I’m pretty sure, but I returned to book to the library awhile ago.)  There’s also a lot of technical terms and techniques employed in comic writing, but it’s not boring at all.  A fair amount of psychology relating to the topic is included.  I learned quite a lot about both the history of comics and the modern styles.  Anyone who enjoys reading comics and graphic novels should definitely check this out.  (Also reviewed at: Jenny’s Books.)

Runaways Volume One by Brian K. Vaughan

I read Runaways Volume One by Brian K. Vaughan while waiting for his other series Y: The Last Man to arrive.  It’s about a group of teenagers who discover their parents are potentially evil superheroes and run away to discover what their parents are up to and how to stop them.  Each of the teenagers has a special skill: magic, alien powers, a psychic link with a pet dinosaur, logic and strategy, science engineering, and super strength.  It’s a fun first volume, and I think I’ll eventually continue with it.

Castle Waiting by Linda Medley

Castle Waiting by Linda Medley is set in a ‘fairy tale land,’ with the first story arc reminiscent of Sleeping Beauty.  After that, the story veers away from the traditional and into the land of pig-nosed infants, circuses, and an order of bearded nuns.  I read that there’s a second volume, but I don’t think it’s been published yet.  I had a nice afternoon reading this outside on the deck, and I’d recommend this to anyone who wants a fun read and likes skewed fantasy or fairy tale stories.

The Eternal Smile by Gene Luen Yang and Derek Kirk Kim

The Eternal Smile by Gene Luen Yang and Derek Kirk Kim is a collection of three stories, a fairy tale, a gold hungry frog, and an internet scam, that aren’t exactly what they seem at the beginning.  There’s a psychological aspect to all three that I didn’t expect, but I absolutely loved.  It added something I’ve never seen in a graphic novel before, although I’m admittedly not an expert.  The art is gorgeous and has a different style in each story.  After reading Understanding Comics, I was able to identify a few Eastern elements present in the art.  Most noticebly, there were a lot of mood panels, which don’t contain any words or actions, simply a shot to let you know where you are and the overall mood the artist is trying to convey.  Anyway, I loved the heck out of this little book, and I actually read it twice.  If I had a rating system, this would get a million stars.

Embroideries by Marjane Satrapi

I read both volumes of Satrapi’s Persepolis earlier this year, and I decided it was time to look into her other works which seem to be kind of companions to PersepolisEmbroideries by Marjane Satrapi concerns an evening with the women in Satrapi’s family drinking tea and sharing stories both about themselves and gossing about others.  The title refers to a procedure that allows women to superficially ‘reclaim’ their virginity, in hopes that their husband will believe them to be virgins.  I found the drawing style to be very similar, but the layout was quite different.  Where Persepolis was told in mainly panels and included chapter headings, Embroideries has a more fluid, no boundaries visual style, which lends itself to the conversational tone of the book.  While it was only a short book about a few women’s experiences with men, love, sex, and marriage in Iran, I throughly enjoyed reading it and learning a bit more about what these women actually go through.

Fables: Legends in Exile by Bill Willingham

Fables: Legends in Exile by Bill Willingham is the first volume in the ongoing Fables series.  The Fables have been kicked out of their home by the Adversary and exiled to New York City.  Snow White’s estranged sister Rose Red has been attacked, or worse.  Snow White, an upper level administrator, and Bigby Wolf, the sheriff, investigate.  I won’t tell you what they find out, but I enjoyed it quite a bit.  Other Fables include Prince Charming, divorced from Snow White, Jack, of beanstalk fame, Beauty and the Beast, who are not without marital problems, and Bluebeard, a supposedly reformed serial wife killer.  I’ve already put the second volume on hold and can’t wait to start it!

Y: The Last Man: Unmanned by Brian K. Vaughan

Y: The Last Man: Unmanned by Brian K. Vaughan is the first volume in the series.  Something happens and all the men in the world die, except two: Yorick and his pet monkey Ampersand (I love their names).  Obviously issues of reproduction and survival of all the species on the planet are paramount.  Yorick is forced to hide, because he doesn’t want to draw attention from the Daughters of the Amazons, a fanatical group who believes the Y chromosome is an aberration the world is glad to be rid of.  I’m going to continue this series to find out what killed off all the males and if the species can be saved.  And of course, to see if Yorick is reunited with his girlfriend, potentially his fiancee, in Australia.

http://jennysbooks.wordpress.com/2009/06/22/understanding-comics-scott-mccloud/

Categories: Review
Tagged: ,

9 responses so far ↓

  • Eva // June 30, 2009 at 11:00 pm | Reply

    I loved this post! I’ve just really gotten into graphic novels this year, and now I’ve put Understanding Comics and The Eternal Smile on my list!

    If you haven’t tried Fun Home, it’s a graphic memoir I loved.

  • Jackie (Farm Lane Books) // July 1, 2009 at 10:21 am | Reply

    I’ve only just started to read graphic novels too. I really struggle to review them. This is a great post!

    I endorse the recommendation for Fun Home – it is really good!

  • Understanding Comics, Scott McCloud « Jenny’s Books // July 1, 2009 at 12:16 pm | Reply

    [...] Nymeth at Things Mean a Lot Kim at Sophisticated Dorkiness 1330V Shananagins [...]

  • rebeccareid // July 1, 2009 at 2:25 pm | Reply

    I’ve been wanting to read Castle Waiting, I glad to hear it’s very good!

  • Nymeth // July 2, 2009 at 6:37 pm | Reply

    I kind of wanted to join Infinite Summer, but there’s too much else I also want to do, too many other books calling my name.

    I agree with you about Understanding Comics, Castle Waiting, Embroideries and Fables, and I really want to read The Eternal Smile and Y.

    PS: Your blog has the coolest name ever!

  • Shannon // July 2, 2009 at 8:29 pm | Reply

    Eva: Understanding Comics and The Eternal Smile were my favorite ones reviewed here. I hope you enjoy them! I read Fun Home earlier this year and absolutely loved it. =)

    Jackie: Thanks, I’m glad you liked it. =) Fun Home was wonderful, and I read recently that Bechdel is working on a new graphic memoir dealing with relationships she’s had.

    Rebecca: I hope you get to it soon!

    Nymeth: Yeah, Infinite Jest is pretty huge, there’s plenty of time to read it later. Thank you, my name’s Shannon, so the blog name is a nickname. =)

  • uenohama // July 2, 2009 at 9:11 pm | Reply

    Brian K. Vaughan is an excellent writer. I whole heartily recommend his Pride of Baghdad.

  • Reinventing Comics, Scott McCloud « Jenny’s Books // July 3, 2009 at 5:26 pm | Reply

    [...] 3, 2009 by Jenny So Shan said that she found it difficult to read Understanding Comics because it was lots of information [...]

  • rebeccareid // October 2, 2009 at 2:02 am | Reply

    Since I commented before, I’ve read both Castle Waiting and Understanding Comics. They’re great!

Leave a Comment